This post may use affiliate links from Amazon and other retailers which may earn a commission for purchases made at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Ever wondered what actually is the difference when comparing the Glock 17 vs 19? Feeling unsure which one you want at your side? At first glance, the two guns may appear identical. But take another look – there are key differences that could tip the scales for which one you get.

Will you lean towards Glock 17’s longer barrel and sight radius that give an edge in accuracy? Or will Glock 19’s smaller size and easier concealment appeal more to your everyday carry needs?

If you’re torn and can’t make a decision, we’ve got your back. This guide is here to help you through every detail, from size differences and magazine capacity to performance on the range. By the time you finish reading, you’ll have the info you need to make an informed decision.

glock 17 vs 19

Table Of Contents:

Glock 17 vs 19: Unveiling the Key Differences

Let’s take a deep dive into two of Gaston Glock’s most popular pistols – the Glock 17 and Glock 19. They are known for their ruggedness and simplicity. These polymer-framed pistols have made waves among gun owners and government agencies since they came out. But what makes them different? Let’s check them out.

Size and Concealment Factors

The Glock 17 is considered a full-sized pistol with an overall length of just over eight inches (8.03oz to be exact) and weighing in at about twenty-five ounces (24.87oz if we’re counting). On the other hand, the smaller size Glock – ‘the G19’, is almost three-quarters of an inch shorter with an overall length of around seven inches (7.28oz precisely), making it easier to carry every day due to its lighter weight which is around twenty-one ounces (21.16oz).

This reduced size not only contributes to better concealability but also improves comfort when carrying this concealed carry pistol on your person all day long.

So long story short so far on the Glock 17 vs 19: The G17 is a full-size pistol and the G19 is a compact pistol meaning the G17 is a little larger than the G19.

Glock 17 vs 19 Grip and Frame

Moving on from lengths and weights, let’s now discuss the grip and the frame. The differences are pretty clear between the two frames and grips which definitely impacts how the gun feels in your hand and handles while shooting.

The Glock 17 has a larger frame that measures up at approximately six-and-a-half inches in height (6.50in), offering more space for your hands which is beneficial for those of you with big hands like myself. However, don’t disregard our compact friend yet. The smaller Glock offers just over five inches worth of grip height that may appeal to those looking for something less bulky while still providing good control when firing rounds off.

Glock 17 vs 19 Grip and Frame Summary: The Glock 17 is larger and better suited to those with larger hands and who want more control over the gun. The Glock 19 is fairly smaller but better suited to those with small hands and those who may be after something easier to conceal.

Magazine Capacity Comparison: The Glock 17 vs 19

The conversation between the Glock 17 vs 19 can’t be had without touching on magazine capacity. That’s like comparing pickup trucks while ignoring their truck bed size.

On one side, we have the Glock 17 with its standard magazine capacity that holds seventeen rounds – that’s two more than you get from the Glock 19. This is a very important point because two extra shots may not seem like much, but if you ever needed them in a life-or-death scenario, you’d wish they were there.

You can always use larger magazines with a Glock 19 to hold more rounds but then the grip essentially becomes the size of a Glock 17. This would make it very similar to the Glock 45 which is my personal go-to but that’s for another time.

Impact on Shooting Experience

A higher capacity gives you more room for error during high-pressure situations, such as home defense scenarios or competitive shooting matches. Imagine being stuck in a situation where you need to use your handgun to save yourself or others; those extra rounds might just make all the difference.

On the other end is the smaller G19 which carries fifteen rounds per standard capacity mag. Not too shabby either. In fact, some gun owners find the Glock 19 easier to handle because of its reduced size.

At first glance, there seems to be only minor differences: A half-inch shorter grip frame here, and slightly less weight there… But put these pistols into real-world use like with everyday carry where fractions matter and every little detail counts towards giving you an edge against adversity. Whether drawing your weapon swiftly from concealment or landing accurate shots under pressure, these seemingly small factors all matter when choosing the best handgun for you.

Barrel Length & Sight Radius Influence on Accuracy

Shooting a pistol accurately isn’t just about skill; the tool in your hands plays an essential role. The Glock 17 and Glock 19 are both excellent choices, but their differing barrel lengths certainly influence your ability to be accurate.

The Glock 17 has a longer barrel of 4.48 inches which allows for greater precision, particularly at larger distances compared to the slightly shorter barrel of the Glock 19 which measures up at exactly four inches.

Glock 17 vs 19 barrel key takeaway: The Glock 19’s is half of an inch shorter than the Glock 17’s.

Longer Sight Radius Benefits

Sight radius also affects aiming precision and accuracy. The length from rear sight to front sight determines how easy it is to precisely aim your firearm. Here’s why: imagine trying to draw a straight line between two points that are half-inch apart versus points that are three inches apart—it’s easier to get it right when they’re further away.

The Glock 17 offers more room for error due to its slide length of approximately seven and one-third inches (7.32″ specifically), making it ideal for increased accuracy especially over long distances.

In contrast, those who favor quicker shooting may appreciate the ease of use offered by the smaller frame size and reduced slide length of the Glock 19 which is 6.85″.

This doesn’t necessarily mean that one’s better than another. It all boils down to personal preference, experience level, proper training, and comfort when handling these polymer-framed pistols on the range or in real-world situations.

Performance & Accuracy: A Range Comparison

The Glock 17 and the Glock 19 both shine when it comes to performance and accuracy, especially on the range. The 9mm cartridge is a popular round known for its cost-effectiveness and recoil management and both the Glock 17 and 19 are chambered in 9mm.

Recoil Control

Felt recoil is an important factor for any shooter, whether you’re into competition shooting or just want greater accuracy. Despite their differences in size and weight, both these Glocks manage to deliver an impressive level of control over recoil.

The heavier Glock 17 might have a slight advantage here because more mass usually equates to less felt recoil. But don’t discount the lighter Glock 19; its compact design lets shooters maintain a firm grip and stability even during fast shooting and rapid-fire sequences.

Achieving greater accuracy with either model isn’t solely about felt recoil though. Training with either tool is paramount to becoming competent with your chosen handgun.

Range Performance Verdict?

No clear winner emerges when comparing the Glock 17 vs 19. While some aspects lean towards one or other depending on your specific needs and preferences, both these guns have proven their worth on the range time after time.

It really comes down to personal preference. Honestly, you should just get both to have them available to you, especially since they are so affordable.

Glock 17 vs 19 Pricing

There is no loser here. Both of these pistols retail for the same price. Depending on the generation and features you can commonly see these popular handguns go for around 500 bucks.

Application Scenarios For The Glock 17 vs Glock 19

The practicality of the Glock 17 vs 19 varies based on their unique characteristics. Let’s dig into some common scenarios where each pistol shines.

Law Enforcement Preferences

A key factor that law enforcement agencies consider when choosing between these two models is size. The smaller size of the Glock 19, coupled with its lighter weight, makes it an ideal choice as a carry gun for many officers.

It’s compact enough to be carried all day without causing discomfort but still packs a punch when needed.

In contrast, many departments often lean towards the Glock 17. Why? They don’t need to worry about concealing their handguns while on the job. Remember the Glock 17 is larger and has a greater mag capacity and a longer barrel length providing better accuracy at extended ranges.

This doesn’t mean one model trumps another across departments though. Some may prefer one over another depending on specific department policies or officer preferences. Many departments mandate a specific firearm to carry which may not even be a Glock and might be a Sig Sauer or Smith and Wesson.

Beyond just law enforcement use though, let’s talk about how your everyday guy might choose between these two pistols because that’s what is more applicable.

Glocks in Everyday Life: Home Defense & Concealed Carry

If you’re looking for something compact yet powerful for concealed carry or self-defense purposes then go no further than Gaston Glock’s popular G19. Its shorter grip frame makes it easier to conceal while providing ample firepower thanks to its standard fifteen-round capacity magazine.

In fact, the Glock 19 is the most popular handgun in America and takes the top spot in our Best Handguns for Beginners guide.

The G17 is more suitable if home defense or competition shooting is your thing. It gives shooters an edge with higher rounds (seventeen) per mag along with slightly better control and accuracy thanks to its longer slide and barrel. But remember, choosing the right Glock really boils down to your personal preference and training.

Choosing Between Glock 17 vs Glock 19 – Factors to Consider

When it comes down to Glock pistols, your choice will largely depend on personal preference and intended use. Both the Glock 17 and the Glock 19 are excellent choices, but they serve slightly different purposes.

Personal Preference Influence

The size of these two pistols could be the determining factor for many. The larger Glock 17 has an overall length of about eight inches and weighs nearly twenty-five ounces. On the other hand, its smaller counterpart is lighter by almost four ounces with a half-inch shorter height for easier concealment.

Your comfort level while holding or carrying these 9mm pistols should also influence your decision. A longer sight radius may give you a slight advantage in aiming precision at long distances but could compromise concealability because of its longer barrel and also grip.

Besides size and weight considerations, capacity magazines play another role in making this tough call between a full-sized pistol versus a compact variant. With a higher magazine capacity of up to seventeen rounds, some gun owners might find themselves leaning towards the Glock 17 for those extra rounds ready at their disposal as opposed to fifteen rounds offered by the Glock 19.

In conclusion, Gaston Glock’s pistols offer versatility that suits varied user needs. From law enforcement agencies looking for reliable service weapons to everyday carry enthusiasts seeking an easily concealed carry pistol there’s a pistol that will suit your needs without compromising firepower potential or reliability.

glock 19

Glock 19

Affordable, reliable and sets the standard for a compact 9mm handgun.

*Price accurate at time of writing

Full size
glock17 gen 3

Glock 17

A great, simple and gold standard for a full size 9mm handgun.

*Price accurate at time of writing


So you’ve delved deep into the Glock 17 vs 19. You’ve navigated through their key differences and distinctive features.

You now know that while both are top-notch choices, they cater to different needs. The Glock 17 with its longer barrel lends itself better for accuracy at range – a potential ally for full-sized leaning folks, or competition shooting.

On the flip side, if concealability is your priority, then the reduced size and lighter weight of the Glock 19 might just be your perfect everyday carry gun.

Remember, whether it’s choosing between these two popular pistols or any other firearm out there – personal preference plays a crucial role. After all, comfort breeds confidence!

In essence: Do your research (just like you did here), assess your needs, and trust yourself to make an informed decision. Also, you could always just get both!

Disclaimer: Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. This means if you click on an affiliate link and purchase the item, we will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through my Amazon links as well. The price of the item is the same whether it is an affiliate link or not. Regardless, we only recommend products or services we believe will add value to our readers. By using the affiliate links, you are helping support our website, and we genuinely appreciate your support.

Similar Posts